Reporting and Escalating Fake Google Reviews

‍

• Flag and report each fake review: Log into your Google Business Profile and flag the suspicious reviews as “inappropriate” (choose the option that best fits, like spam/fake content or conflict of interest)​. Include details if prompted (e.g. noting the review mentions a doctor that doesn’t exist at your practice). Google’s team will review flagged reviews, but this can take several days.

• Use Google’s complaint form for spam attacks: For a coordinated attack (multiple fake reviews at once), submit a report through the Google Business Redressal Complaint Form​. This form lets you directly report spam or policy violations to Google’s compliance team. Explain that you’ve been hit by fake reviews, provide your business listing details, and attach evidence (screenshots of the reviews, notes that the reviewers are not actual patients, etc.). Google has indicated it’s acceptable to use this form for fake review issues even if it’s designed for spam listings​.

• Document evidence of falseness: Prepare a brief dossier of why each review is fake. Note discrepancies like reviewers describing services or staff that don’t exist, or all 7 reviews coming in a short timeframe from first-time reviewers. This information will be useful when you escalate to Google support or, if needed, legal channels. Showing clear evidence (e.g. “Reviewer refers to a male doctor, but our clinic has only female practitioners”) can strengthen your case.

• Leverage the Google support community or social media: If you don’t see timely results from the normal reporting process, consider posting your situation on the official Google Business Profile Help Community forum. Experienced Product Experts there can sometimes flag your case to Google staff. Additionally, you can reach out to Google Business Profile support on social media (for example, tweeting @GoogleMyBiz on Twitter/X with a summary of the issue). Provide your business name and mention that you’ve already flagged the fake reviews – this can sometimes expedite attention to your case.

Contacting Google Business Support for Removal

• Reach out via Google Business Profile Support: Use the “Contact us” feature in the Google Business Profile Help Center to get in touch with Google support​. You can usually choose to chat, request a call, or email. Explain that your profile is under a fake review attack and that you need assistance removing reviews that violate Google’s policies (spam/fake content).

• Provide clear details and evidence: When speaking or writing to Google support, be specific. Give them the dates and content of each fake review, the usernames involved, and why the reviews are fraudulent. Reference Google’s review policies (like the prohibition on fake/spam reviews and content not relevant to an actual customer experience) to back up your request. For example, note that the reviews contain obviously incorrect information about your business (which a real customer wouldn’t mistake). If you have screenshots or a document with your evidence, share that with the support team​.

• Get a case ID and follow up: Ask the support representative for a case or reference number for your issue. This way, if nothing happens in a few days, you can re-contact Google and refer to that case number. Persistence is key – if you don’t see the reviews removed in the timeframe Google promised, politely follow up via the same support channel and ask for an update​. Google support can sometimes be slow, so a gentle reminder that the issue is ongoing (and causing harm to your business) is appropriate.

• Escalate the issue if needed: If the first-line support agent isn’t helpful or just tells you to wait, you can request escalation. Ask if a Google Business Profile specialist or policy team can review the case, given the evidence of policy violations. You may also try contacting support again at a different time to reach a different agent. Consistently reiterate the key points (multiple reviews, clearly fake, violating content guidelines) and that you’ve already flagged them. Showing that you know the process (mention that you used the Redressal form or community forum, if you did) may encourage them to take your case seriously.

Here's an example:

"Subject: Urgent Assistance Needed – Fake Review Attack on Google Business Profile

Hello,

I’m reaching out for help regarding a sudden fake review attack on our Google Business Profile:
[Your Business Name] – [Link to your Google profile]

On [Insert Date], we received [number] of one-star reviews within hours. These are clearly fake based on the following:

• All reviews are from random accounts with no prior activity.
• Some refer to a “male doctor” — but our office has only female providers.
• The reviews contain generic or false details, inconsistent with any real patient experience.
• We do not have any records of these names in our system.

I have flagged each review individually and also submitted the Google Redressal Form, but I’d like to request further help from the support team to expedite the investigation and remove these reviews under Google’s Prohibited Content Policy (fake/spam reviews).

This attack is causing reputational harm and distress to our staff and patients.

Attached is a document/screenshot with:

• Each reviewer’s username
• Date and time of the reviews
• Explanation of why each is fraudulent

Please review this and let me know if additional documentation is needed. Also, kindly provide me with a case ID so I can follow up if necessary. If this cannot be resolved at this level, I’d like to request escalation to the Google Business Profile Policy team.

Thank you so much for your support in protecting the integrity of our business profile."

Best regards,
[Your Full Name]
[Your Position]
[Phone Number]
[Email Address]

Legal Avenues (DMCA & Defamation Takedowns)

• Use a DMCA takedown if applicable: If any of the fake reviews include content that infringes your intellectual property (for instance, if the attacker copied text from your website or posted an image you own in their review), you can file a DMCA request to Google. Google’s “Report Content for Legal Reasons” portal allows you to specify copyright infringement, and Google will remove or block content that violates copyright law​. This is a niche solution – it only applies if the fake review contains your original copyrighted material (unlikely in most text-only reviews, but worth noting).

• Consider a defamation removal request: False statements that seriously defame your business (e.g. accusing you of crimes or gross misconduct that are blatantly untrue) might qualify for removal via a defamation claim. Google’s legal removal system has an option to report defamation, but be aware: Google typically requires a court order to act on such claims​. In practice, that means you’d likely need to sue the review posters for defamation and obtain a judgment declaring the review content defamatory. Only with that legal documentation will Google usually remove a review for defamation​.

• Consult legal counsel for persistent attacks: If the fake reviews are causing significant damage and Google won’t remove them through normal channels, consulting an internet defamation attorney is an option. They can advise on the likelihood of success in pursuing the reviewers (or the person behind them) legally. In a lawsuit, you might sue “John Doe” if the identity is unknown, then subpoena Google for information. The goal is to get a court to declare the review false/defamatory, after which Google can take it down​. Keep in mind this is a last resort due to cost and time – it’s most appropriate if the reviews are part of a sustained smear campaign.

• Leverage other legal frameworks if relevant: If the content of the reviews violates other laws (hate speech, privacy violations, etc.), mention this in any legal report to Google. For example, if a review somehow included someone else’s personal data or was a clear case of extortion, those could be separate grounds for removal. Also note that regulators are cracking down on fake reviews in general – the U.S. FTC (Federal Trade Commission) has proposed heavy fines for businesses posting fake reviews​. While this doesn’t immediately remove your reviews, it indicates that posting fake reviews is illegal in many jurisdictions. Your attorney might use such laws to pressure the source of the attack or to inform law enforcement if appropriate.

Restoring Your Reputation After Fake Reviews

• Encourage real patients to leave reviews: One of the most effective counters to fake negative reviews is a wave of genuine positive reviews from happy customers​. Reach out to patients you know are satisfied – for example, right after a successful appointment or via a follow-up email – and kindly ask them if they would share their experience on Google. Even a few new 5-star reviews can significantly improve your overall rating and push the fake ones down. (Don’t offer incentives for reviews, as that violates policy, but a friendly request is perfectly fine.) A study found that it can take dozens of positive reviews to balance out one negative​, so the more authentic feedback you gather, the better.

• Use reputation management tools: Consider using services or software that help streamline review collection and monitoring. For instance, platforms like Podium, Birdeye, Swell, or ReviewTrackers are popular with small businesses for sending automated review invites via text/email and consolidating your reviews in one dashboard. These tools can remind customers to leave a review and alert you instantly when a new review (good or bad) comes in​. Utilizing such tools can help boost your volume of real reviews and quickly flag issues, thereby diluting the impact of any spam attacks.

• Publicly respond to the fake reviews (carefully): It may be counter-intuitive, but crafting a professional public response to each fake review can help more than it harms. If a fake review is still live after a day or two, treat it like a legitimate complaint and reply to it​. For example, you might say: “Thank you for your feedback. We take patient concerns very seriously. However, we cannot find any record of your visit or the situation described. Please contact our office directly at [phone/email] so we can address this immediately.”​ This kind of response is polite and addresses the comment without validating the false claims. It signals to other readers that the review might be bogus (since you can’t locate the person or incident) and that you, as the owner, are attentive and willing to resolve issues. Not responding at all can actually be worse, as it leaves the fake accusations unchecked – a calm rebuttal gives readers your side of the story​.

• Maintain a professional tone: When responding, do not accuse the reviewer of lying or get into an angry back-and-forth​. Even though you know the review is fake, respond as if a real customer made a complaint. Acknowledge their concern broadly and reiterate facts (like “we have no male doctor on staff, so we’re unsure about this review, but we’re here to help resolve any confusion”). By staying factual and courteous, you come across as trustworthy to anyone reading the reviews​. Avoid personal attacks; your goal is to reassure future potential patients that even if a bizarre negative pops up, you handle it professionally.

• Promote recent positive feedback: In addition to Google, encourage patients to share reviews on other platforms (Facebook, Healthgrades, Yelp, etc.) as appropriate. You want a strong overall online reputation. If the fake reviews made you drop in rating, a surge of authentic positive feedback will not only restore your Google rating but also show up in search results, making the attack less impactful. Sometimes local businesses also share testimonials on their website or social media – consider doing that with recent kind words from patients (with permission), to highlight that the negative remarks are an anomaly.

Preventing Future Review Attacks

• Monitor your reviews proactively: Set up measures to catch fake reviews early. Ensure you have Google Business Profile notifications turned on for new reviews (Google can email the business owner whenever someone posts a review). It’s also wise to periodically check your profile even if you haven’t been notified, just in case. Early detection means you can flag and address a spam attack before it snowballs. Some third-party tools mentioned earlier will send you real-time alerts for any new reviews across platforms​, which can be very helpful.

• Educate and involve your staff: Discuss the importance of online reviews with your team so they understand the impact. If they receive any odd phone calls, emails, or in-person comments that threaten bad reviews (it does happen), they should inform you immediately. Staff can also help encourage happy customers to leave reviews, creating a stronger buffer against any future negatives. Basically, make review monitoring and encouragement a routine part of your customer service process – this vigilance can discourage attackers, since they’ll see you respond quickly, and can help catch issues early.

• Build a resilient review profile: Continuously collect genuine reviews over time. A business that regularly accumulates positive reviews will be more “attack-proof” – a burst of 5 or 7 fake negatives will be more obvious and statistically less damaging if you already have 50, 100, 200 real reviews backing you up. Also, Google’s algorithm itself might filter out suspicious reviews if you have an established history of legitimate feedback. Patterns like a sudden cluster of negative reviews from new accounts are a red flag, and while Google’s automated systems aren’t perfect, they do sometimes catch and remove fakes on their own. The more authentic engagement your profile has, the better those systems can work in your favor.

• Use online monitoring tools and alerts: Set up a Google Alert for your business name (so you know if you’re mentioned on websites or forums, which sometimes precedes or follows coordinated attacks). There are also reputation monitoring services that watch reviews on major sites – consider these if you want extra peace of mind. Many small businesses rely on agencies or software to get a single dashboard of all their reviews. This isn’t just for convenience – it means if someone tries the same stunt on another platform (say, suddenly 1-star Yelp reviews), you won’t miss it. Being aware of your online presence broadly can help you respond to attacks outside of Google as well​.

• Have a crisis gameplan: It sounds like you’ve unfortunately learned this the hard way, but use this experience to create a protocol for any future incidents. For example, decide who will handle flagging and contacting Google, have a template ready for public responses to fake reviews (so you can respond swiftly with a level head), and perhaps have contact info for a legal advisor on hand if things ever escalate. Hopefully you won’t need it, but being prepared means a potential future attack will be less stressful and less damaging, because you can respond quickly and decisively.

• Stay within guidelines (no “revenge” tactics): Lastly, as frustrating as fake reviews are, avoid any temptation to respond in kind (e.g., do not attempt to post fake positive reviews for your business or trash the attacker or competitor if you identify them). Stick to ethical practices – businesses that try to cheat the system often get penalized​. By focusing on legitimate reviews and proper channels, you’ll not only resolve the current issue but also safeguard your business’s long-term credibility.

Should you respond publicly to fake reviews? In summary, yes, a polite public response will generally help rather than hurt. It demonstrates transparency and concern. Google and other customers can see that you as the owner acknowledge feedback (even false feedback) and try to address it. This can only improve trust. The only way a public response could harm you is if it’s unprofessional – for example, an emotional or angry rant will reflect poorly on your business. As long as you keep it calm and factual, a public reply is a chance to correct the record and show that you care about your reputation and your clients​.

‍

Each response is essentially a message to everyone who reads that review in the future, so responding thoughtfully is an effective reputation management step in its own right.

‍

For more helpful tips, strategies, ideas, and marketing advice, join my weekly newsletter here.